by Joshua Day » December 28th, 2011, 2:07 pm
If you watched the course of the voting closely, you noticed that Brogue inched up at a more or less constant rate. Its community overlaps pretty completely with the roguelike community as a whole; the big games that passed it up have brought in more totally new players than Brogue has. So before voting requests started popping up in the big communities, Brogue was ahead; after that, they surged forward. But it's still a fair enough measure -- those games do have huge communities for a reason! And if anyone here hasn't tried any of those games, or at least taken a look, I recommend that you do so.
This year, Brogue established itself with the Roguelike community. For total conquest, there's always next year.